Who fought I Americans (Horatio Gates and Benedict Arnold) vs. British (John Burgoyne).
What was at stake: The survival of the United States.
The King's army was marching down from Canada to end the rebellion, General Burgoyne proclaimed, and it was the duty of all loyal colonists to help it. Those who refused and sided with the rebels would suffer "devastation, famine, and every concomitant horror that a reluctant but indispensable prosecution of military duty must entail." More specifically, he said, "I have but to give stretch to the Indians under my direction (and they amount to thousands) to overtake the hardened enemies of Great Britain and America."To be fair, Lt. Gen. John Burgoyne was bluffing.
"Gentleman Johnny" had earned his nickname not by his flamboyant lifestyle but by his humanity. He had abolished flogging in his command, although it was practiced in every army, including the Continental. Burgoyne had forbidden his Indian scouts to kill civilians. He told them he'd pay only for live captives. He wasn't being totally altruistic, of course: Only live captives could provide information.
Burgoyne had witnessed the bloodbath on Breed's Hill two years before. He knew that the war could not be won without the cooperation of at least some of the colonists. As far as he could see, the center of the rebellion was New England, where the radicals had gained control of the militia and what remained of the colonial assemblies. New England was also the portion of the colonies closest to Canada. If New England could be isolated and subdued, the other colonies might abandon their ridiculous Declaration of Independence.Gentleman Johnny had a plan, and, as a member of Parliament, he had the political connections to get it approved. He was going to move, by land and water, down Lake Champlain and the Hudson River, to cut off New England. Howe would move up the river from New York City and take the rebels in the rear.
The British armies would meet at Albany. Barry St. Leger, leading an army of American Tories and Indians, would march down the Mohawk to Albany. And Tories from all over backwoods New York and New England would reinforce the King's forces. Col. Philip Skene, one of Burgoyne's Tory officers, had convinced him that the backwoods were full of Tories.Actually, there were many loyalists in the backwoods. Sir William Johnson, who founded a fur-trading empire in western New York and Pennsylvania, had imported hundreds of them from Ireland and Scotland. Johnson, born William McShane in Ireland, was also the Mohawk chief Warraghiyagey. He had secured the loyalty of the Iroquois tribes.
Johnson was dead, but his son, Sir John Johnson, and his second-in-command, John Butler, had formed Tory regiments. St. Leger was to lead them and 1,000 Mohawks under William Johnson's brother-in-law, Joseph Brant. Brant was an Indian chief educated in Connecticut and welcomed in London society.Fair proportions of Burgoyne's army were American loyalists. One was a lieuten-ant named David Jones, serving in the corps led by Acting Brig. Gen. Simon Fraser. Jones had an extra incentive.
His sweetheart, Jane McCrae, was waiting for him in Albany. Pretty "Jenny" McCrae, in fact, couldn't stand the waiting. She moved in with a Mrs. McNeill, a relative who had a cabin in the woods north of Albany, to be closer to her David. Mrs. McNeill, of course, was also a Tory. One of her cousins was Simon Fraser, the daring Scot who led Burgoyne's vanguard.
Jenny McCrae
The fortress of Ticonderoga, overlooking the narrow waters of Lake Champlain, was considered the Gibraltar of America. Burgoyne had Fraser circle the fort and scout out the territory. The Scot reported that a mountain overlooking Ticonderoga was not occupied. Burgoyne had cannons hauled up the mountain. When the Americans saw the guns, they abandoned Ticonderoga and fled into the woods. Burgoyne decided to pursue them instead of sailing to the end of the lake and following the road that led from there to the Hudson River.That was his first mistake.
The English general had 7,500 men, 42 cannons, and a supply train consisting of hundreds of carts. The Americans felled huge trees across every possible trail and skirmished with his vanguard. They slowed Burgoyne's progress to about a mile a day. The British were inching through a jungle-like forest, advancing on an unseen enemy. Burgoyne had to know what was ahead of him. He sent out his Indian scouts.
One of the first things the Indians saw was the cabin of Mrs. McNeill. Two of them burst into the cabin, grabbed Mrs. McNeill and Jenny McCrae, stripped them and started back to the British camp. On the way back, they quarreled over which would receive the reward for Jenny McCrae; apparently believing the British would pay more for a beautiful young woman than for an aged widow. The Indian who lost the argument shot Jenny McCrae and scalped her.
When she got to the British camp, Mrs. McNeill told her cousin the general what happened. Fraser, beside himself with fury, went to Burgoyne. Burgoyne, too, was outraged. He ordered that the Indians be hanged. But St. Luc de la Corne, leader of Burgoyne's Indians, said that if anything happened to the murderers, he'd take all his men and go home. Burgoyne pardoned the Indians.That was his second—and biggest—mistake.
Word of what happened spread all through New England and New York. Burgoyne had unleashed his Indians, and they were killing everyone, whether Patriot or Tory. Men picked up their muskets and rifles and set out for the American camp. The American army, which was only about half the size of Burgoyne's at the start of the campaign, grew rapidly.Burgoyne's army, on the other hand, was shrinking. The British suffered short-ages of everything, especially food. Philip Schuyler, the American commander, had ordered all the farmers in the area to destroy their crops and drive off their livestock to prevent the British from living off the land. Characteristically, Schuyler, a Hudson Valley patroon despised by the democratic New Englanders, left his own vast estate intact.
Disasters on all sides
To gather food and recruit Tories, Burgoyne sent Lt. Col. Friedrich Baum and 700 soldiers toward Lake Champlain. Baum's force consisted of British, American Tories, German mercenaries, and Indians. The Germans included 170 dismounted dragoons, encumbered by huge broadswords and bayonet-proof jackboots, which covered the knees. Baum spoke no English, but he had Philip Skene as an interpreter. Slogging through the woods, Baum heard that Patriot militia were planning to attack. He asked for reinforcements. Burgoyne sent 700 more Germans under Lt. Col. Heinrich Breymann after Baum.
Both the colony of New York and the colony of New Hampshire claimed the territory they approached. But its inhabitants called it the independent Republic of Vermont.In New Hampshire, John Stark, who had foiled Howe's flanking movement at Bunker Hill, took 1,500 militiamen and headed west. Five hundred more militia from Massachusetts soon joined him. The Jenny McCrae story was having an effect.
Baum at first thought these armed backwoodsmen were coming to join him. They practically surrounded his force without opposition, then hit both flanks. Baum's Indians fled at the first shot. The whites were driven together in the center, and Stark launched his main attack. An American shot blew up one of Baum's ammunition carts. Baum ordered his dragoons to cut their way out with swords, but seconds later, an American bullet killed him. Baum's force disintegrated.
Just then, Breymann and his 700 Germans appeared. They were just in time to meet the Green Mountain Boys, Vermont's own army, which had arrived to help the Massachusetts and New Hampshire militia. The Germans tried to form a line and fire volleys, while the New England rustics fired from behind trees. Breymann was losing men fast; his troops were shaken. He told a drummer to beat a slow roll, the international request for a truce. To the Americans, a slow roll was just so much noise. They continued firing. The Germans stampeded from the field. By day's end, Burgoyne had lost 207 killed and 700 captured, along with four cannons. The Americans had 30 killed and 40 wounded.
While this was happening in the East, another disaster was taking place in the West. St. Leger's Tories were unpopular enough in the Mohawk Valley, but his Mohawks were hated and feared. Patriot militia reactivated old Fort Stanwix to block St. Leger. St. Leger besieged the fort. A Patriot militia force tried to break the siege, but was led into an ambush by Joseph Brant. The result was bloody and indecisive. The British abandoned the field, but the Americans were too cut up to go on.At this juncture, Benedict Arnold, recently reassigned to the north by George Washington, appeared. He found a mentally disabled man named Hon Yost Schuyler and convinced him to tell the Indians that Arnold, who had proved his brilliance as a general in this area the year before, was coming with a huge army. The Indians believed that the mentally deficient were incapable of lying. They quickly decamped. When the Tories saw that the Mohawks were gone, they followed.
But for Burgoyne the worst news of all was that Howe was not coming. Howe had his own plan for ending the war: Capture Philadelphia, the rebel capital. Aided by the inefficiency of the British cabinet, Howe got his plan approved while Burgoyne was on the high seas. He left Henry Clinton with 4,000 men in New York City. Clinton was not about to try driving through to Albany. If he moved many men out of the city, Washington would snap it up.While all this was going on, it occurred to Washington that something important might be happening in the north. So, along with Arnold, he sent Daniel Morgan and 1,000 riflemen. Horatio Gates, a genial Englishman who was anything but a fiery leader, had replaced the unpopular Schuyler.
Johnny rolls the dice
The American army was growing daily as armed citizens, individuals as well as militia units, arrived at Gates's camp. Gates said he was afraid to expose these raw recruits to Burgoyne's Indians, although by this time, the Indians had deserted the British. Gates put his new men to work digging earthworks a little south of Saratoga. At this point, the numerical odds had been reversed. Gates had two men for every man of Burgoyne's. Gentleman Johnny, though, never shrank from risking everything on the draw of a card. He attacked.
Simon Fraser led 2,000 men around the American left, seeking to seize a hill over-looking the rebel trenches. At Gates's headquarters, Arnold begged the commanding general to hit the British while they were in the open. Gates preferred to wait for them in his trenches. Finally, he let Arnold, commanding the left wing, send Morgan to counterattack. Morgan's riflemen drove back Fraser's scouts. Then the British light infantry appeared and pushed Morgan's men back with a bayonet charge. Arnold sent in two Continental regiments in order to stop the British. But after a hard fight, those troops, too, were driven back. Burgoyne ordered a general advance all along the line.
Arnold noticed that a gap had opened between the Fraser's corps and the main British body, led by Burgoyne. He led more troops into the gap. The British closed up, and Arnold's entire corps was engaged. Arnold rode back to ask for reinforcements, but Gates, with a horde of reserves, refused to send any. And he confined Arnold to headquarters. Meanwhile, Maj. Gen. Adolph von Riedesel, who commanded the British left, took his German mercenaries toward the sound of the guns. He hit the Americans in the flank and drove them back before darkness ended the fighting. Burgoyne had won a Pyrrhic victory. He had 600 killed, wounded, or captured. The Americans suffered 65 killed and 218 wounded. Of the troops engaged, 33 percent of the British and 10 percent of the Americans were casualties. Gates should have counterattacked, but he stayed in his trenches.
Burgoyne now heard that the rebels had cut his communications and captured most of his supply ships. And Clinton wrote that he had been reinforced and was going to move north. Gentleman Johnny had no choice but to attack.
Once again, Simon Fraser led the attack. Once again, Gates moved most reluctantly. He had already deprived Arnold of his command for being too aggressive. He allowed Morgan to take his brigade and Enoch Poor's to meet Fraser.Morgan's riflemen performed their customary long-range carnage, and Poor's brigade, its numbers swollen to 800 by recent additions, pushed the British back with a bayonet charge. Gates allowed one more brigade to engage Riedesel's Germans, who were again moving up to support Fraser. Then Arnold, unable to contain him-self, mounted his horse and led the charge against Riedesel's corps. The Germans fell back to their own trenches.
Fraser, on his big gray horse, dashed frantically up and down the line, rallying his men. The British stopped retreating and began to advance. Morgan called a rifleman named Tim Murphy, one of the best shots in the army, and told him to kill Fraser. Murphy fired twice with his double-barrel rifle, reloaded, and fired again. Fraser fell from the saddle at the third shot, and his aides carried the dying general to the rear. The British line broke. Arnold led the Americans right into the British right wing redoubt, where he was shot in the leg.
Burgoyne had to retreat, but there was nowhere to retreat to. And there was no way Clinton could reach him. He surrendered his army. Surrendered to a mob of peasants. It was unthinkable. London was shocked.In Paris it was considered a miracle. To take advantage of the miracle, France declared war on England, and brought Spain and Holland into the fight with her. Britain, bogged down in a land war that could not be won in America, now had to face the three strongest sea powers after herself. The Revolutionary War would drag on for more than five more years, but the result was inevitable.
A new nation was created, and a rabble of peasants proved that they could successfully rule themselves without a king. A few years later, that inspired the ancient kingdom of France, and the new colonies of Latin America to do the same. The world had been changed most decisively.